Wendy Katz, an associate professor of art history at the University of Nebraska, was conducting a research project on art criticism in nineteenth-century newspapers at the Library of Congress in Washington, D.C. She came across a poem in the June 23, 1842 issue of New Era entitled “To Bryant, the Poet of Nature.” The poem addresses William Cullen Bryant, a poet who was at that time editor of the New York Evening Post.
The poem was signed simply “W.W.” But Dr. Katz believes the poem was written by Walt Whitman. She wrote an article in the most recent issue of the Walt Whitman Quarterly that explains her theory that the poem was written by Whitman. “The peer review process meant that the editor of the journal and two other scholars felt that the argument was persuasive,†Dr. Katz said.
Dr. Katz is a graduate of Occidental College in Los Angeles. She holds a master’s degree from the University of Michigan and a Ph.D. from the University of California, Los Angeles.
Here is the text of the 1842 poem:
To Bryant, the Poet of Nature
Let Glory diadem the mighty dead—
Let monuments of brass and marble rise
To those who have upon our being shed
A golden halo, borrowed from the skies,
And given to time its most enduring prize;
For they but little less than angels were:
But not to thee, oh! nature’s OWN, we should
(When from this clod the minstrel-soul aspires
And joins the glorious band of purer lyres)
Tall columns build: thy monument is here—
For ever fixed in its eternity—
A monument God-built! ‘Tis seen around—
In mountains huge and many gliding streams—
Where’er the torrent lifts a melancholy sound,
Or modest flower in broad savannah gleams.
— W.W.